News:

January 2024
The ABDA has relaunched this forum with upgraded software, appearance and features. All the old content remains. Users should log in and update their membership profile.
Only financial members of the ABDA can register to be part of this forum. Non-members can browse the open sections of the forum and post questions to "Ask a Director" and "Online Directing" without registration.

Main Menu

Damage from Misbid( deviation from system agreement)

Started by Mike Trafalski, 18 May, 2024, 08:00 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Print
Go Down Pages1
User actions

Mike Trafalski

18 May, 2024, 08:00 PM
Bidding
S   W   N    E
1C  P  1NT  2D
3NT  P  P    P

Declarer plays 3NT making 6 tricks.

On the play of AKQXX   by E  (partner has JXXX).  At the end of the hand Dec calls Director.

East states that over a 1NT opening bid , 2D shows 8-13 HCP and a 5 card major. Director awards NS an adjusted score of5C making 11 Tricks.

E explain  he missed the 1C opening bid by S.

How do you



Matthew McManus

#1
06 June, 2024, 08:54 AM
On the evidence presented, there does not appear to have been any infraction. 2D was simply a mistaken bid. There was nothing that required alerting by East or West. West has not taken any suspicious action which may have allowed for East having forgotten the system or made a misbid. Unless the director is able to identify some infraction, there are no grounds for awarding an adjusted score.
Print
Go Up Pages1
User actions